American restaurants

The Pequot Inn

4.3 74 reviews Closed 775 Montauk Ave, Fishers Island, NY 06390, United States

Discover this place

If you're seeking a hidden gem on Fishers Island, look no further than The Pequot Inn. This American restaurant, located at 775 Montauk Ave, has become a beloved nook for locals and visitors alike. Renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and passionate staff, many diners describe it as a place with soul where the camaraderie shines brightly.

Guests rave about the mouthwatering dishes, particularly the smash burger paired with crispy fries, which have drawn numerous accolades. The creative twists on classic fare, like their unique Caesar fries and robust pepperoni pizza, showcase the culinary flair behind the bar and grill. A fine selection of wines and local brews adds to the experience, inviting patrons to unwind with something refreshing.

Moreover, the staff, including favorites Ian and Zoe, foster a welcoming environment that feels like coming home. Visitors have noted the lively dance floor on weekends, making The Pequot Inn not just a dining spot but a lively destination for night-time fun. This is truly a spot worth traveling to; it offers a memorable experience that captivates the senses and keeps you coming back for more.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Dine-in

Dining options

Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with The Pequot Inn before visiting.

Reviews for The Pequot Inn

4.3

74 reviews

100%

21%

16%

12%

Review highlights

Based on 74 reviews

The Pequot Inn is widely recognized for its warm, inviting atmosphere and standout American cuisine, particularly its creative and flavorful dishes like burgers, seafood, and unique sides. Guests often highlight the exceptional quality of both food and drinks, including innovative cocktails and well-crafted bar fare. The establishment’s friendly, attentive staff and lively ambiance, with weekend parties extending into late hours, contribute to its reputation as a beloved local hotspot. Visitors appreciate the combination of a cozy bar setting that feels like home and an energetic vibe that includes dancing. Overall, The Pequot Inn is praised for delivering a memorable and soulful dining and social experience on Fishers Island.

Chandler Reedy

Aug 08, 2025

Very special place. Food is awesome, bar is perfect and staff is even better. Place has soul. Thanks to everybody for doing what you do. Keep it going all night long and forever.

Lily Starbuck

Jul 29, 2025

Like coming home. I love this bar. Ian & Zoe are the best. Can’t go wrong with a smash burger & fries

Steven Ballot

Jul 27, 2025

Drinks and pizza and Caesar fries and cod bites and cheesy bread. What a great experience. We had a pepperoni pizza that had great flavor and I asked for a side of jalapeños, which I added to my slices. Absolutely delicious. The Caesar fries were quite unique. I’ve never had them before but it was love at first bite. That shows creativity can be delicious ! If you’re ever on One by Nine, this is a must stop. One by Nine ~ if you know, you know.

David Hughes

Jul 04, 2025

Excellent little bar and grill slash Dance Floor tucked away in the heart of Fishers Island. They know how to make a drink. I had shrimp cocktail while waiting on the ferry. Has the friendliest staff I've ever encountered. New goto when on the island my only complaint is I didn't get enough time here, but I will be back. Like and follow for more hidden travel well

Taha Güneş

Jun 13, 2025

It has a great team of employees. The food is very delicious. They party after 10pm on Friday and Saturday nights.